In Defence of Three- and Four-Year-Olds

The IB needs to create an Early Years Programme.

I say this as someone who has spent nearly thirty years teaching three- and four-year-olds. This is not a general concern about early childhood education. It is a specific call from a specialist in this age group for the youngest children in IB schools to learn within a framework that was designed for them.

Zero to five: a foundational stage we already know exists

The developmental case for treating zero to five as a distinct and protected stage is neither new nor contested. Decades of research in neuroscience, developmental psychology, and education have built it, and its message is consistent.

Erik Erikson’s stages of psychosocial development identify the early years as the period when children establish their foundational sense of trust, autonomy, and initiative. Jerome Bruner showed us that young children learn through action, story, and direct experience long before they are ready to learn through abstraction or formal instruction. Both theorists, working from very different traditions, arrived at the same essential conclusion: the early years are qualitatively different from what comes after, and what happens in them is foundational and lasting.

Modern neuroscience has sharpened this picture considerably. New Zealand neuroscience educator Nathan Wallis, drawing on current brain research, describes the early years as the period of peak neural plasticity, when the brain forms connections at a rate it will never again reach. Wallis is specific about what this means in practice: the social-emotional brain, the systems governing relationships, regulation, and connection, must be developed first and most deeply in the early years, because it is the foundation on which all later cognitive development depends. Pushing children toward formal literacy and numeracy before these foundational systems are well established does not accelerate development. According to Wallis, it can undermine it.

This period is also critical because of what we know about how children’s social cognition develops. The timeline is more nuanced and more informative for education than was once thought.

Research on the Theory of Mind, the ability to understand that other people have thoughts, beliefs, and knowledge different from our own, shows that this capacity develops gradually across the early years, not in a single leap. Onishi and Baillargeon (2005) demonstrated that infants as young as 15 months show implicit sensitivity to false beliefs, suggesting the roots of social understanding begin far earlier than previously recognised. Wellman and Liu (2004), mapping the scaling of Theory of Mind tasks across early childhood, showed that children progress through a consistent sequence of social-cognitive milestones from understanding desires, to understanding beliefs, to grasping that beliefs can be false over the course of the preschool years.

What does this mean for three-year-olds in practice? Research by Martin Hughes showed that what Piaget described as childhood egocentrism is better understood as cognitive overload. When tasks are made humanly meaningful and grounded in real social situations rather than in abstract arrangements, young children demonstrate social awareness far beyond what earlier frameworks suggested. The challenge for three-year-olds is not that they are incapable. It is that suppressing their own knowledge to imagine someone else’s ignorance, or to follow a line of inquiry that someone else determined, places significant demands on executive function that is still very much in the process of formation. This is not a limitation to be corrected. It is a developmental reality, and it has direct implications for what we should and should not ask of three- and four-year-olds in the classroom.

Meins et al. (2002) added a crucial relational dimension to this picture. Their research showed that mind-mindedness in caregivers, the disposition to treat children as mental agents with their own thoughts and intentions, and to narrate those mental states aloud, is a significant predictor of children’s Theory of Mind development. Children who grow up around adults who say things like “I wonder what you’re thinking” or “she might not know that yet” develop social cognition measurably faster.

Alison Gopnik’s research (2012) extends this further, framing young children not as passive recipients of knowledge but as active, hypothesis-testing learners who, in her view, function like scientists. Children explore, experiment, revise their understanding, and generate new theories about how the world works, all through self-directed activity. Gopnik’s work directly challenges the assumption that young children need structured instruction to learn. Instead, they need environments rich enough to explore, relationships secure enough to take risks, and the freedom to follow their own curiosity.

This is the developmental portrait of a three- or four-year-old: a child whose social cognition is actively and rapidly developing, who learns best through secure relationships, rich language and self-directed exploration. Whose brain is at its most plastic, and whose executive function is still building the capacity to sustain the demands of structured, collective inquiry.

Crucially, none of this research says young children cannot engage with big ideas, complex concepts, or sustained inquiry. It says they engage with those things in a specific way: through self-directed exploration, in responsive relationships, at their own pace, following their own questions. That is the standard the research sets. It is also the standard against which we need to honestly measure the expectations currently placed on young children in IB classrooms.

Play is how children learn.

Play is not a method. It is the mechanism through which all young children learn. The evidence is consistent, clear, and global.

First, we need to be specific about what play means here, because the word has been stretched beyond its original meaning. We are not talking about a teacher-designed activity built from a child’s interest, or a structured task with playful elements; we are talking about play in which the child has genuine autonomy and agency, where the adult’s role is to observe, be present, scaffold when invited, and follow the child’s lead.

Peter Gray, research professor at Boston College and author of Free to Learn, has spent his career documenting what happens when children are given genuine freedom to play. His research shows that free, self-directed play is how children learn to solve problems, regulate their emotions, build relationships, take risks, and recover from failure. These abilities develop through play because play is the one context in which children have genuine agency over the outcome. The motivation is intrinsic, the consequences are real, and the learning is retained because it is contextual to the child.

The LEGO Foundation’s substantial body of research on learning through play, conducted across multiple countries and contexts, consistently finds that child-led, playful learning is among the strongest predictors of the holistic skills children need to thrive: creativity, collaboration, communication, and self-regulation are skills that predict long-term life outcomes more reliably than early academic attainment.

What happens when play is removed or restricted in the early years? The evidence is explicit. Schweinhart and Weikart’s landmark HighScope Preschool Curriculum Comparison Study followed children across three different preschool approaches, including direct instruction. They found that children in the direct instruction group showed early academic gains similar to those of children in play-based programmes. But significantly worse social outcomes in adulthood: higher rates of social difficulties, lower rates of community involvement, and more troubled life trajectories. The early gains did not hold. The social and emotional deficits did. Carlsson-Paige (2015) reinforces this: children pushed into early academics often show initial skill acquisition but fail to sustain it, because the deeper cognitive and social-emotional architecture built through play remains underdeveloped. The payoff for formalising learning too early is not there. And what is lost in the process carries long-term consequences.

Play is also where the most powerful academic foundations are actually built. Children playing with language hear thousands of words in rich, motivated, contextually embedded situations, which build vocabulary depth. That depth is one of the strongest predictors of reading success. Children who see cat and mat on a flashcard are given symbols without reference. Children who have held a cat, argued about cats, and pretended to be cats understand those words more deeply. Children building with blocks, measuring with water, and experimenting with sand are constructing a mathematical understanding of volume, weight, spatial reasoning, and cause and effect that is lived and meaningful before it becomes abstract and symbolic.

What happens when play meets the wrong system

The IB’s framework, concepts, Approaches to Learning, Learner Profile, and transdisciplinary themes are not the problem. These are genuinely good tools for thinking about how children learn and who they are becoming.

What does not naturally lend itself to the developmental needs of our youngest learners in a play-based environment are the systems within the PYP. The expectation that units are pre-decided before the children arrive, that all children engage with the same unit at the same time, and that the unit planner is the primary planning and accountability document. These systems create a tension with what developmental research tells us about how young children learn, especially about what three- and four-year-old brains are actually ready for.

The research we have already examined tells us exactly why. Children are active hypothesis-testers who follow their own questions, in their own sequence, at their own pace, not a schedule set by someone else. The social-emotional brain develops through responsive relationships, not pre-planned content delivered to a group. And children move through social-cognitive milestones gradually and unevenly. Wellman and Liu showed that assuming all children in a class are ready for the same conceptual encounter at the same time is developmentally false.

But Martin Hughes’ framing of cognitive overload is the most important concept in this argument.

Three- and four-year-olds are not incapable; they are remarkably capable. But their executive function is still developing. So, asking them to suppress their own thinking, follow a predetermined line of inquiry, and engage on someone else’s timeline places demands on a cognitive system that is not yet fully built.

A structural training gap

The IB currently has no dedicated Early Years coordinator role and no specific early years training for the adults responsible for the programme as a whole. PYP coordinators who carry that responsibility very often come from primary school backgrounds. Some may have taught kindergarten, but very few have worked with three- and four-year-olds.

This is not a criticism of individuals, rather a description of a structural gap. These coordinators arrive with the best of intentions and a deep understanding of the PYP, which is designed to serve primary-aged children. The challenge is that without specific early childhood expertise, the natural reference point is the primary classroom: it is assumed that what works for seven-year-olds can be simplified and softened for three-year-olds.

The IB has produced guidance to support early years practice within the PYP, and that guidance reflects genuine care. But guidance delivered within an unchanged structural framework, one that still requires pre-planned units, assigned concepts, and documented ATL evidence, does not produce the fundamental shift in thinking this age group requires. However, a dedicated EYP coordinator role, filled by someone with specialist knowledge of early childhood, would change this.

The consequence of not having that protection is predictable. Teachers already doing rich, observational documentation of children’s learning are then required to translate it into a separate unit planner. They are repeating the same information, but in a format that doesn’t fully capture the ebb and flow of play. The accountability questions that follow reveal a deeper assumption: that all children should be engaging with the same concept, in the same unit, at the same time. Whole-class inquiry makes that assumption easy to satisfy. Child-led, intrinsically motivated, play-based learning doesn’t work because children aren’t all in the same place at the same time. But because the system is built to verify whole-class engagement, it pushes teachers to predetermine learning rather than follow it.

This is where genuine child-led play slowly erodes. Because the system cannot easily accommodate what does not fit, play is slowly reshaped to fit it instead. Everyone engages with the same inquiry at the same time. And the three-year-old who has spent three days absorbed in building finds herself redirected toward something decided for her before she walked through the door.

A dedicated Early Years Programme changes this. It gives teachers the structural permission to follow the child. It gives our youngest learners a system built around who they actually are.

And the evidence tells us what follows when that happens. The World Bank’s 2022 assessment of early childhood investment linked quality early years provision directly to lifetime earnings, health outcomes, and national productivity. This is not just good pedagogy. It is one of the highest-return investments any institution or any society can make.

When we get early childhood right, children thrive. And when children thrive, everything else follows.

The time is now

The IB’s current reach extends to children as young as three years old. Within that span, early years educators in IB schools worldwide are doing extraordinary work.

The recent publication of Finding Our Way: Developing a Shared Pedagogy by Fiona Zinn and Anne van Dam is one marker of the rich thinking emerging within the IB early years community. It centres joyful curiosity, intentional practice, and treats the complexity of teaching in the early years with the seriousness it deserves. The conversation is growing, and that is precisely why this is the right moment for the IB to make a structural commitment to match it.

An IB Early Years Programme would recognise that children aged three to five require a framework built from their developmental reality, not scaled down from an older one. It would mean a dedicated coordinator role: someone with specialist knowledge of early childhood who understands this developmental stage and can support teachers in understanding what play, assessment, and documentation look like in an IB context. They understand what a framework feels like when it is introduced through relationships and play.

What an IB EYP could look like

This is my vision, offered as a provocation for conversation.

The woven basket

New Zealand’s early childhood curriculum, Te Whāriki, takes its name and its architecture from the image of a woven mat. The strands of the curriculum, well-being, belonging, contribution, communication, and exploration, are not in separate boxes. They are woven together, inseparable, reflecting the child’s lived experience.

However, I see the EYP more like a woven basket, the same philosophy of interconnection. But as the weaving continues, the basket grows upward. It builds and holds more. Its strength comes not from any single thread, but from the way every thread connects to every other.

That is the model for an IB Early Years Programme. The concepts, the Approaches to Learning, the Learner Profile, and the transdisciplinary themes are the threads interwoven, each one strengthening the others. Together, they create something strong enough to hold the whole child, their curiosity, identity, and growing capacity to engage with the world.

And as the children grow, the basket grows with them.

This is the model I am drawing from for my vision of an IB Early Years Programme. The concepts, the Approaches to Learning, the Learner Profile, and the transdisciplinary themes should be woven threads, weaving in and out of one another, complementing and enriching each other, the way learning through play actually happens for young children.

Form does not belong to How the World Works. Form belongs to everything, from the shape of a block tower to the pattern of a footprint in mud. A child engaged in deep, dramatic play is not engaging with a single concept. She is encountering form, function, connection, and perspective simultaneously. She is demonstrating thinking, social, and self-management skills all at once. She is being a risk-taker, a communicator, and a thinker. That is how play works: it is the connective energy that ensures the IB framework isn’t a set of pillars standing apart, but each a part of a whole. It is where the ‘what’ we learn and the ‘who’ we are becoming are woven together.

But the mat is not static. It grows with the children. What is woven for a three-year-old looks different from what is woven for a five-year-old. The three-year-old encounters a form in the sandpit, without knowing its name. The four-year-old begins to notice it, name it, and return to it. The kindergartner starts to talk about it, question it, and use it deliberately in their inquiry.

This is how the EYP introduces the art of structured inquiry gradually, across the age range. Three-year-olds hear the framework in the teacher’s language, feel it in the environment, and encounter it in the flow of their play. Four-year-olds begin to notice it, name it, and return to it. The teacher asks a little more of them, deeper questions, closer observation, the first tentative threads of structured inquiry when the children show they are ready. By kindergarten, the spiral has brought them to the point where they deliberately and joyfully engage in structured inquiry, because the mat was woven carefully enough to bring them there.

The EYP’s task is to let the threads move as they naturally do in and out of each other, across every moment of every day, so that the framework lives in the play rather than sitting outside it.

Documentation as planning

In the model I am proposing, documentation is the planning. The rich, observational, narrative documentation that skilled early years teachers already do becomes the evidence of framework connections.

Early years teachers are already doing extraordinary documentation work. They are already capturing what children say, what they build, what they wonder about, and what they return to. Requiring them to translate that into a separate unit planner is not an improvement on good practice. It doubles the labour and serves the system, not the children.

But documentation-as-planning only works if the documentation is genuinely rich, and by richness here, we mean articulation. Writing an observation and then tagging concepts, ATL, or the learner profile is not enough. The professional act is the explanation: She explored how changes in their sandpit design (e.g., packing sand, adding stones, ‘I need to put more here’) caused the water to behave differently, directly observing cause-and-effect relationships. That sentence does what a unit planner cannot: it tells the story of the learning, names the connection to the framework within the experience, and preserves the child’s voice within the same passage.

This is also where the developmental research stays active. Writing about what a child was thinking, as specifically and honestly as possible, is the teacher practising mind-mindedness, the Meins disposition that the research shows is one of the most powerful things an adult can offer a young child. Rich documentation is not administrative. It is one of the most important pedagogical acts a teacher performs.

The child’s voice is not part of the documentation; it runs through it all. The Reggio Emilia tradition of documentation as dialogue, showing children their own thinking and inviting them back into it, is a practice the EYP should explicitly draw on.

What does this look like for each age group?

Three-year-olds: weaving the mat

At this stage, the mat is being woven. Children at this age build foundational skills and gain experience with autonomy and agency in their own learning. They are discovering they can choose where they go, what they investigate, who they play with, and what they return to.

The teacher’s planning emerges entirely from the documentation. The framework is present in the environment, in the teacher’s language, and in the questions asked. The Concepts, Approaches to Learning, and Learner Profile Attributes are introduced through narration, in the moment, when the connection is real and belongs to the child.

I notice you’ve been thinking about the shape of things, how different shapes do different things. In the IB, we call that form.

Where a project emerges organically, something that has genuinely captured the attention of multiple children, the teacher has the professional autonomy to draw the group around it. The project runs as long as the children are genuinely in it. The minute engagement ends, the teacher lets it go and waits for the next real moment. You cannot plan the start date of a project that comes from the children. You can only be ready for it.

Four-year-olds: building the basket sides

Four-year-olds inhabit the same fundamentally play-led, documentation-driven environment. The mat is still being woven, but the weave is becoming richer. The teacher asks deeper questions, listens more closely, and documents more specifically. The children are bringing more to their play: more sustained investigation, more complex negotiation, more elaborate theory-making.

Many four-year-old groups will also include children who are four, turning five; children who have been five for a while, whose executive function is noticeably further along; and children whose capacity to sustain and revisit an idea has grown. A skilled teacher reads this. And if, based on genuine observation of where the children are, the teacher sees the group is ready, they may choose to introduce a structured inquiry unit.

This is not a requirement. It is a professional option, taken when the children are ready for it and not before. The unit is chosen because it connects to something the children are already genuinely interested in; it grows from the children’s world, not from a planning meeting. It runs for as long as it has genuine life, and stops when it doesn’t. A four-year-old group that never reaches that point has not fallen short. They have spent the year building exactly the autonomous, agentic, deeply curious foundation that the spiral is designed to grow from.

Spiralling up: kindergarten and the skill of structured inquiry

The kindergarten EYP model asks teachers to run a minimum of two units and a maximum of four, sequential or concurrent, the teacher’s choice, based on where the children are, rather than what the calendar requires. Teachers who run two units and go slowly and deeply are not doing less. They are doing exactly what this model intends: taking the time to build the skill of collective inquiry. What does it mean to wonder about something together? What does investigation feel like as a group? How do we share what we found? Rather than moving through content for its own sake.

This is not about preparing children for what comes next. It is about giving them the genuine experience of structured inquiry at a pace their development can sustain, and their curiosity can inhabit. If the teacher adds a third or fourth unit, they do so in response to their children. The teacher who stays with two is responding to children who need more time to go deep. Both are right. Both are doing what the EYP is designed to allow.

What kindergarten is explicitly building is the skill of being in a guided inquiry classroom, the experience of wondering collectively, investigating together, and beginning to articulate thinking on request rather than only in the moment. Children at this level begin to practise reflection more deliberately. The teacher models it, invites it, and makes it feel like something they already do. I noticed you changed what you were doing halfway through. What made you decide to try something different? The child who can answer that question, even partially, is spiralling up. That is the work of kindergarten.

What the planner might look like

The EYP planner is not a simplified replica of the PYP planner. It is retrospective rather than predictive, built from what the children did. It is open and expansive, more like a mind map than a traditional unit planner, allowing the teacher to trace connections among children, moments, and different threads of thinking as they emerge and intersect.

The foundation

The three- and four-year-olds are already in IB schools. They are learning, playing, building, and wondering, and they are doing it inside a framework whose systems were not designed for them, even when the framework itself is right.

They deserve a structure that is.

Sue Tee recently shared a quote with me from the OECD’s Building Strong Foundations for Life that says everything:

“If you want to understand the future of a country, do not start in its universities. Start in its kindergartens, crèches and nurseries. Because by age 5, the story is already being written. Early childhood development is not just a warm-up act for education; it is the foundation. It shapes whether a child will thrive in school, feel confident in life, and ultimately find their place in society.”

The IB has built something extraordinary. It has shaped the education of children across the world, in schools that cross cultures, borders and languages. It has asked those children to be inquirers, thinkers, communicators, and caring human beings.

Now it is time to ask the same of itself and to build the foundation that those children deserve before any of that begins.

References

  1. Bruner, J. S. (1966). Toward a theory of instruction. Harvard University Press.
  2. Carlsson-Paige, N. (2008). Taking back childhood: A proven roadmap for raising confident, creative, compassionate kids. Hudson Street Press.
  3. Devercelli, A., & Beaton-Day, F. (2022). Better jobs and brighter futures: Investing in childcare to build human capital. World Bank Group. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/35062
  4. Erikson, E. H. (1950). Childhood and society. W. W. Norton & Company.
  5. Gopnik, A. (2012). Scientific thinking in young children: Theoretical advances, empirical research, and policy implications. Science, 337(6102), 1623–1627. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1223416
  6. Gray, P. (2013). Free to learn: Why unleashing the instinct to play will make our children happier, more self-reliant, and better students for life. Basic Books.
  7. Hughes, M. (1975). Egocentrism in preschool children [Unpublished doctoral dissertation]. University of Edinburgh.
  8. Malaguzzi, L. (1993). Your image of the child: Where teaching begins. Child Care Information Exchange, 96, 52–56.
  9. Meins, E., Fernyhough, C., Wainwright, R., Das Gupta, M., Fradley, E., & Tuckey, M. (2002). Maternal mind-mindedness and attachment security as predictors of theory of mind understanding. Child Development, 73(6), 1715–1726. https://doi.org/10.1111/1467-8624.00501
  10. Ministry of Education. (1996). Te Whāriki: He whāriki mātauranga mō ngā mokopuna o Aotearoa: Early childhood curriculum. Learning Media.
  11. OECD. (2026). Building strong foundations for life: Results from the 2025 Early Learning and Child Well-being Study. OECD Publishing. https://doi.org/10.1787/02bf8efe-en
  12. Onishi, K. H., & Baillargeon, R. (2005). Do 15-month-old infants understand false beliefs? Science, 308(5719), 255–258. https://doi.org/10.1126/science.1107621
  13. Schweinhart, L. J., & Weikart, D. P. (1997). The High/Scope Preschool Curriculum Comparison Study through age 23. Early Childhood Research Quarterly, 12(2), 117–143.

Leave a Reply